« Pet Food Recall Online Panel | Main | Friday iPod Challenge, the "SHE LIVES!" edition »

10 May 2007


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


elizabeth - glad you also found those reads interesting. As for the China Dialogue site, check their link here for at least a bit of info on who they are:


When I first stumbled upon info about Zhou Qing's articles on this site:

....I didn't see a link to his writings so Googled until I found links where I could read them. Hence the China Dialogue's link.


elizabeth - I also just found this site's description of China Dialogue & what they're about:


"China Dialogue 中外对话 is a completely bilingual website about environmental issues, with a strong China focus. The website is a little like a blog: there are comments and a very open editorial policy. As its name suggests, the website aims to encourage dialogue between China and the rest of the world about problems facing the environment, so even user comments are translated to ensure that everything is bilingual.

Edited by veteran China hand and prominent British writer Isabel Hilton, the site currently features an essay by best selling novelist Ian McEwan, as well many other contirbutors."

Hope that info helps.

elizabeth R.

Thanks for the links, Ally. I'll check them out.


“Blue Buffalo said then that it didn’t know that the concentrate came from China. That’s not surprising: C.J. Foods, which made the cat food for Blue Buffalo, didn’t know either, says C.J. Vice President Jerry Krueger. C.J. got the ingredient from a U.S. supplier. It was imported by San Francisco-based Wilbur-Ellis.”

This can never happen again. Ingredients must be certified to show exactly where they come from. And we can no longer accept the excuse of “I didn’t know”. I applaud Blue Buffalo for dropping their ANI contract and hope they find a good replacement, but they and all other pet food companies must know where their ingredients come from.


Good! I hope this bankrupts AN and MF.


I have trouble trusting these businessmen, It seems to me that it's easy to say the right thing, but how is it verified! I remember too many businessmen being caught telling lies and businesses being caught for wrongdoing paying fines but NOT admitting to wrongdoing, and having all evidence and records sealed. How can we really tell if we are being told the truth about the products we are being sold? The owners of these businesses are so rich that they have nothing in common with their customers and do not understand what average peoples lives are like. It really doesn't matter to them that some people are emotionally crushed by the loss or illness of their pets, and some spend money they can't really afford for their treatment. The rich ARE different!


All these weeks the companies haven't been saying much but I think their trust was broken as much as ours and it has been a very hard wakeup call for them as well. Unfortunately far too many pets had to die or have their health now compromised. But I did say earlier that the Universe has a way to correct wrongs. All those who have lost loved furbabies know that they are looking down from the bridge clapping their paws.


"I have trouble trusting these businessmen, It seems to me that it’s easy to say the right thing, but how is it verified!"

Comment by Peter — May 10, 2007 @ 5:45 am

Me too. Especially worried they may say "All our products are US grown" and then turn around and issue a recall, saying "foreign ingredients were added without our knowledge". Is it unrealistic to think a large company could have control over their ingredients and manufacturing of their products? It seems to me that if better quality control protocols were put into place and followed, this could be achieved.


The Truth is finally Known:

Twiddle Dee D and Twiddle Dee Dum, Fee Fi Fo Fum, I smell rotten fish - Twiddle Dee D and Twiddle Dee Dum, what sound does the FDA Giant make when it too succumbs - oh sin and corruption, silence money and pay backs, stock options and hush money - Twiddle Dee D and Twiddle Dee Dum - The FDA giant will soon be jobless and a forgotten tiny insignificant crumb -


It won't matter if ANI or MFI go bankrupt. Their CEO's, VPs, accountants and misc. other higher-ups will all get positions at whatever NEW company gets formed form their previous company's dissolution or at a competitor's facility. It will still be the same head people in charge making the same lousy decisions to keep their money-grubbing hands and their financial backers' pockets full of that All-American $.


It's probably a corporation. They can just create another one and it's business as usual.


The American People are taking this opportunity to remind pet food manufacturers of their legal responsibility to ensure that all ingredients used in their products are safe for our pets consumption.

(Oh, and by the way, that goes for our food also. Get it?)


Oh, one last thing. We are staying involved and will be keeping the pressure on - or to put it lightly “harassing the bejesus out of you guys” until you comply with the wishes of American Pet Parents.

Have a nice day.


Class In Session.

Lets observe how far "they", the insiders can pump Menus Stock up today. (While no ones watching of course)

Will Menu enjoy "happy days are here again?"



Good article. But it lacked passion I thought. I am Samiecat in the comments. I couldn't help myself.


Here in the good 'ol U.S. of A., we are fortunate many of our U.S. reporters are doggedly trying to bring the truth of recall news to light. However, David Goldstein reports today over at HorsesAss that his oft snarky & erudite blog has now been BANNED IN CHINA:

"Sometime late Tuesday or early Wednesday the Chinese government blocked Internet access to HorsesAss.org, apparently fearful of what its citizens might learn of their own unregulated food supply — like the fact that Chinese vegetable proteins and livestock feed are routinely adulterated with scrap melamine and scrap cyanuric acid, and that in addition to renal failure, chronic exposure may cause cancer and reproductive damage. You know, stuff like that."

To quote the Peking Duck, an expat blog in Taipei:

Gee......"Fancy that."

David's blog entry "I've been banned in China!" can be found here:



I am beginning to believe (in my faith-based dining way) that the processed food industry in general, not just pet food, is an 'anything goes if you can get away with it' sort of thing. Should any of it actually be trusted? Is that something that came into being during the 1950's? How did that mentality become trustworthy? It was fake then and it's fake now.

If you want to have anything absolute to say about the composition of your meals, you have to start from scratch and don't buy processed foods... for your pets or for yourself. And although I'm learning that finding good ingredients is a real task in itself, our voice is in how we shop.

The past couple weeks have given us a pretty good view into the human foods supply too (although the FDA certainly hasn't intended for us to see through the perfect storm of mass confusion). Our food supply is far from pristine... and I'm beginning to believe it's not that different than the food supply in China.


Ally! Now how am I going to get my cheap kidney transplant with all this Chinese renal failure going on?


If I could ask for indulgence while I fantasize a little here... One of my life dreams is to live on a farm where we could grow our own food and have some farm animals (basically as pets - I don't eat meat). I understand it would take hard work but I'm not lazy and I'd be willing to do the work to have my own safe, fresh foods. I picture myself milking a cow, churning my own butter, working in wheat fields, growing oats, vegetables, fruits, etc.

Reality for me is that (save for that elusive lottery win) we will never have a farm. But I still have the desire for safe, fresh foods - for the humans and pets in the family. There must be some companies out there who are willing to not just TALK THE TALK but who actually do make the extra efforts to produce safe, fresh foods. I understand those foods will cost more than foods using 'bottom of the (melamine) barrel' scrap ingredients from China. But the problem I'm having now is that many of the foods (pet and human) which I *thought* were safe, fresh foods have turned out to be no better than if I had saved some money and bought the cheaper foods.

Won't some companies step up to the plate and perform this needed service of providing safe, fresh foods? There is surely a profit to be made - monetarily and otherwise.


Comment by Cynthia — May 10, 2007 @ 7:37 am

Uh.........don't look at me, Cynthia! Perhaps making that the Daily Double question for Alex?


Comment by Cynthia — May 10, 2007 @ 7:37 am

'Now how am I going to get my cheap kidney transplant with all this Chinese renal failure going on?'

And the Jeporday answer to that.."What is melamine in our food supply."


I have yet to see any sincerity from any of the pet food companies. They are trying their best to assure us that their food is safe, but they are still pointing fingers and saying it wasn't their fault. That's a bunch of bull. I own a small business and sell products that I don't manufacture and if ANYTHING is wrong with them, I (ME) make it right. That's what I get paid for, and believe me, I'm not raking in the kind of profits these companies are.

To all of these companies, this is nothing more than a 'non-significant' blip that will pass. While there really is no monetary compensation that will bring back a dead pet, many pet owners will be in courts for years hoping for justice. The sad part is that the monetary toll will be nothing compared to the emotional toll this will take on alot of people. They will be reliving their anger and grief for so long.

Not only have we accumulated vet bills, our tax money will pay for the trials and the lawyers will walk away fat. P&G, Menu, Nutro, etc., will continue to prosper. Look how much of our tax money has already been spent on this - FDA hearings, compensation for farmers, lab testing, trips to China...on and on. Have any of the pet food companies offered compensation for ANY of that? Here's another reason for the PFI to lay low. Don't let the American public realize how much money they've spent on this fiasco. Wonder what the CEO's bonuses will be next year?

Sorry to be so negative, but that's the reality of this situation. Remember that old saying - Actions speak louder than words? Time to Act PFI!


I mean - Jeopardy. I sure butchered that word!


Sorry that was so long. I'll be sending that to my senators and congressmen.



By Associated Press | May 10, 2007

As reported on The Boston Globe

"SHANGHAI -- China vowed yesterday to crack down on contaminated and sometimes deadly food and drugs after a string of revelations about the safety of Chinese products."

"China has long suffered adverse publicity tied to its lax enforcement of food and drug safety, but the present round has been especially worrying."

full story here:


Well gosh golly gee willickers. Think it's about time? I mean unless aside from all the melawhoozit ingredient palooza in everything from pet food to cakes and hey! - introducing a unique way to give yourself antibiotics: eat catfish containing the stuff (?!!!), I dunno.......maybe, just maybe there might be a problem here?

Back in 2004, Zhou Qing thought so, as did the Lettre Ulysses Award for the Art of Reportage (http://www.lettre-ulysses-award.org/about.html) when he was nominated for their short list for reporters who's "passion is reality and their works enrich our understanding of the world.". I found both Zhou Qing's articles from September 2006 most enlightening:

"China's food fears (part one)":


"Concerns about the safety of China’s food are on the rise...Qing Zhou looks at the underside of food production, from opiates in soup to pesticides in pickles."

"China’s food fears (part two)"


"In the second part of his report into the food industry, Qing Zhou issues a stark warning to Chinese consumers and asks what steps can be taken to improve food safety."

Very brave and interesting reads. You too can have ‘Industrial Salt 'Not for human consumption' included in your pickled foods, aluminum added to your bread sticks, or better yet, disgruntled employess over pay cuts urinating and spitting in noodle dough that often drops on the dirty floor yet gets tossed back in the container dontcha know.

New & improved ingenious ways of adding spice to food stuffs the Chinese way! Be afraid kiddies. Be very afraid.


Comment by slt — May 10, 2007 @ 7:43 am

The stockholders want larger quarterly dividends.


I popped into the grocery store yesterday and bagged some yellow apples. Then, I stopped and looked at all the apples. I dumped the bag and picked a few from Washington State and left the unknown origin apples at the store. Difference in price is .28 pound.

We desperately need COOL (Country of origin labeling). I will gladly pay a higher price for food not coming from China or any other country not on par with food safety standards.

Junk food is expensive and leaving that at the store will more than make up for a price difference. I feel the same way about better pet foods with human quality ingredients; they need to eat less without all the junk food fillers. In the end the price should be just a little more.


Steve, You're right. Investors have a choice about how much to risk and where their money goes. I don't get a choice as a taxpayer about how much or where it goes - don't quite sound right, does it?


Safeway doesn't list where their fresh produce comes from - so I ask the produce person to find out for me - I bought a cabbage left everything else - too disgusted for words! Ugh!



Are we the only ones who can find these articles?

Does the FDA/USDA/EPA/CDC not have computers?

What needs to be revealed before they stop imports? Human body parts in the food?

Hell even the Chinese say their food isn't safe how much more do we need?

sam (head can't even explode anymore)



"Are we the only ones who can find these articles?"

I'm not Steve, but to anser your question: I seriously doubt it Too much evidence points to the contrary. Folks sleuthing the 'net for the latest news keep discovering news articles & headlines altered numerous times, or FDA documents original filing dates mysteriously changing in the wee hours of the weekend or thingies pulled up on a Google search suddenly not at the link once you make the jump. But Google's "cached" holder often knows. Oh how it does & quite a nifty tool too. Grab those screen shots people before they finally get *poofed* into oblivion.


Hey on the good news front, those of us still feeding Natural Balance, They have added an email list that you sign up for and if there are any recalls they will notify you directly.

Finally something positive.



“Are we the only ones who can find these articles?”

I seem to recall in one of the head exploding comments by Dr. A that part of the problem is that the FDA has old computers . . .


"… American Nutrition said in a statement it didn’t do anything deceitful by using the rice protein ingredient. It said the pet-food formulas, per the customers’ requests, were “rice-based” and so it selected rice protein as a “fortification source” from the “same family.”"

Uhhhhh...yeah. Except what about the products that were'nt supposed to have any rice product in them at all, like the Canine Caviar Beaver and Turkey - those clearly state on the label "grain-free" and are only supposed to have beaver or turkey in them...

Nice try ANI, but that bird don't fly.

elizabeth R.

Interesting reads those China dialogues on food safety that Ally put up. Scary stuff. Hope our Olympians are taking their own food to Beijing!

I am not at all familiar with this reporter or the China Dialogue site/blog. In general I sort of like to know where my internet info is coming from, who is funding it, and what motivators/biases might be inherent. Can anybody help out with the history or ownership of this China Dialogue site? Thanks.

The comments to this entry are closed.